Void Formation During Reflow
Quality & Inspection Standards
PRODUCTS CENTER
Get Custom Quote
PRODUCTS CENTER
Void Formation During Reflow – Quantification & Root Cause Analysis Using IPC‑TM‑650 Test Methods
Voids are gas‑filled cavities trapped within solder joints during the reflow process. Excessive voiding reduces mechanical strength, increases thermal resistance, and can cause electrical failure under high current or thermal cycling. This engineering framework from UltroNiu describes the application of standardized IPC‑TM‑650 test methods to quantify void area, identify void formation mechanisms, and link voids to material or process parameters. Methods covered include X‑Ray Inspection (2.4.52), Microsection (2.1.1), Solder Paste Volatiles Analysis by TGA (2.3.40), Ionic Cleanliness (2.3.25), Flux Residue (2.3.45), and Wetting Balance (2.4.14). IPC‑TM‑650 provides only the test procedures; acceptance criteria for void size and percentage must be defined by users.
Table of Contents
- Scope – IPC‑TM‑650 Methods for Void Analysis
- Void Formation Mechanisms & Corresponding TM‑650 Tests
- X‑Ray Inspection (2.4.52) – Void Area & Distribution
- Microsection (2.1.1) – Void Morphology & Location
- TGA (2.3.40) – Solder Paste Volatiles & Outgassing
- Ionic Cleanliness (2.3.25) – Flux Residue & Void Contribution
- Flux Residue (2.3.45) – Entrapped Organic Material
- Wetting Balance (2.4.14) – Solderability & Void Correlation
- Test Coupon Design for Void Qualification
- Sampling & Documentation per IPC‑TM‑650
- FAQ – Void Formation Testing
- Void Analysis Test Checklist
1. Scope – IPC‑TM‑650 Methods for Void Formation Analysis
IPC‑TM‑650 provides test methods to measure void characteristics (size, location, percentage) and to analyze root causes (solder paste volatiles, ionic residues, surface contamination). This framework covers:
- Quantification of voids using 2.4.52 X‑Ray Inspection and 2.1.1 Microsection
- Analysis of solder paste outgassing using 2.3.40 Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA)
- Measurement of ionic residues that may cause gas entrapment using 2.3.25 Ionic Cleanliness
- Detection of flux residues using 2.3.45 Flux Residue Test
- Wetting behavior correlation using 2.4.14 Wetting Balance
IPC‑TM‑650 does not specify:
- Maximum allowable void size or void percentage
- Acceptable volatile content in solder paste
- Ionic cleanliness limits
Users must define these limits based on product reliability requirements.
2. Void Formation Mechanisms & Corresponding IPC‑TM‑650 Test Methods
| Void Type / Cause | Formation Mechanism | IPC‑TM‑650 Test Method | Measured Parameter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outgassing voids (solder paste) | Volatiles in flux evaporate during reflow, trapped as gas | 2.3.40 TGA | Weight loss % vs temperature (volatile content) |
| Pad surface contamination voids | Organic or ionic residues decompose, releasing gas | 2.3.25 Ionic Cleanliness | µg NaCl eq./cm² |
| Flux entrapment voids | Incomplete flux evaporation, trapped under component | 2.3.45 Flux Residue | Residue area / color |
| Micro‑voids (IMC interface) | Kirkendall effect, Ni‑Sn IMC formation | 2.1.1 Microsection (with SEM) | Void density at interface |
| Large voids in BGA balls | Misprinted paste, insufficient solder volume | 2.4.52 X‑Ray | Void diameter, area % |
| Wetting‑related voids | Poor pad solderability, gas trapped during spreading | 2.4.14 Wetting Balance | Wetting time, force |
3. X‑Ray Inspection (IPC‑TM‑650 2.4.52) – Void Area & Distribution
X‑ray inspection is the primary non‑destructive method to quantify void size, count, and area percentage in solder joints, especially under BGAs, QFNs, and large passive components.
- Procedure: Use real‑time X‑ray or 2D radiography at appropriate resolution (typically 10‑30 µm pixel size). Capture images of each joint. Use image analysis software to measure void diameter and area.
- Key metrics: Void diameter (µm), void area as percentage of joint area, number of voids per joint.
- Application: Compare voiding across different reflow profiles, solder paste lots, or pad finishes. Monitor process stability.
- Limitation: X‑ray cannot distinguish void depth or morphology. Use microsection for that.
4. Microsection (IPC‑TM‑650 2.1.1) – Void Morphology & Location
Microsectioning provides detailed information on void location (bulk solder vs IMC interface), morphology (round vs irregular), and relation to intermetallics.
- Procedure: Prepare cross‑sections through selected joints (e.g., those with high X‑ray void percentage). Polish and etch to reveal IMC layers.
- Key observations: Void location (interface vs bulk), shape (spherical vs irregular), presence of cracks or IMC separation.
- Application: Distinguish between outgassing voids (spherical, in bulk) and Kirkendall voids (small, at IMC interface).
5. Thermogravimetric Analysis (IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.40) – Solder Paste Volatiles & Outgassing
TGA measures the weight loss of solder paste as a function of temperature. Excessive volatile content (>5‑10%) increases void risk.
- Procedure: Heat a small paste sample (10‑20 mg) from room temperature to 300°C at 10‑20°C/min under nitrogen. Record weight loss vs temperature.
- Key metrics: Weight loss at preheat temperature (150‑200°C), total weight loss up to 260°C.
- Application: Compare different solder paste batches or flux types. High weight loss during the soak zone correlates with outgassing voids.
6. Ionic Cleanliness (IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25) – Flux Residue & Void Contribution
Ionic residues (chlorides, bromides, organic acids) can decompose during reflow, generating gas that forms voids. This method measures extractable ionic contamination.
- Procedure: Wash a known board area (typically 100‑300 cm²) with 75% isopropanol/water solution. Measure solution conductivity or use automated cleanliness tester.
- Output: µg NaCl equivalent per square centimeter.
- Application: Correlate voiding with board cleanliness. High ionic levels (>1.56 µg/cm²) may indicate flux residues or process contamination.
7. Flux Residue (IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.45) – Entrapped Organic Material
This method detects visible flux residues under components, which can indicate incomplete flux evaporation and potential void sources.
- Procedure: After reflow, inspect areas under components using optical microscopy or chemical staining. For BGAs, dye & pry may be combined.
- Output: Qualitative (residue presence) or semi‑quantitative (area percentage).
- Application: Identify if excess flux or insufficient preheat is causing trapped residues under large components.
8. Wetting Balance (IPC‑TM‑650 2.4.14) – Solderability & Void Correlation
Poor pad wetting can cause gas entrapment during solder spreading. Wetting balance quantifies solderability and can predict void susceptibility.
- Procedure: Test PCB pads or component leads using ROL0 flux at reflow temperature (e.g., 255°C for SAC). Record wetting time and force.
- Application: Compare wetting performance of different surface finishes (ENIG, OSP, ImAg). Pads with long wetting time (>1.5 s) show higher void rates.
9. Test Coupon Design for Void Qualification
A dedicated void test coupon shall include:
- BGA land patterns (0.8 mm, 0.5 mm pitch): For X‑ray void measurement and microsection.
- Large passive pads (1206, 0805, 0603): Voiding common in chip components.
- QFN thermal pads: Large ground pads prone to voiding.
- Ionic cleanliness test area: 100 cm² of bare copper or solder mask (per 2.3.25).
- Test points for daisy‑chain: Not required for void analysis but useful for reliability correlation.
10. Sampling & Documentation per IPC‑TM‑650
- X‑Ray void measurement: Minimum 10 BGAs or 30 passive components per condition. Report void area % for each joint (mean, standard deviation).
- Microsection: 5 cross‑sections per void condition (e.g., high void vs low void).
- TGA: 3 samples per solder paste lot.
- Ionic cleanliness: Test 2 boards per lot (or per condition).
- Documentation: Reflow profile (peak temp, soak time, ramp rates), paste lot number, board surface finish, and all test results.
11. FAQ – Void Formation Testing with IPC‑TM‑650
Q: What is the maximum allowable void percentage for BGA solder joints?
A: IPC‑TM‑650 does not specify limits. Typical industry guidelines vary from <25% for consumer to <10% for aerospace. Users must define based on reliability testing.
Q: Which IPC‑TM‑650 method best distinguishes void types?
A: X‑Ray (2.4.52) gives void size/area; Microsection (2.1.1) reveals location (bulk vs IMC). TGA (2.3.40) identifies outgassing potential. Use all three for root cause analysis.
Q: Can IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25 be used to correlate voiding with board cleanliness?
A: Yes. High ionic contamination (>1.56 µg/cm²) often correlates with increased voiding, especially if residues contain halides. Measure as‑received and after reflow.
Q: How many voids are acceptable in a QFN thermal pad?
A: Not defined by IPC‑TM‑650. Many users specify total void area <50% of the pad, with no single void >20% of pad area. Acceptability depends on thermal and electrical requirements.
Void Formation Analysis Checklist (IPC‑TM‑650)
- 1. Test coupon includes BGA, passive, and QFN thermal pad patterns.
- 2. X‑Ray inspection (2.4.52) performed on all components; void area % recorded per joint.
- 3. Microsection (2.1.1) prepared on high‑void and low‑void samples; void morphology documented.
- 4. TGA (2.3.40) performed on solder paste lot; weight loss % up to 260°C recorded.
- 5. Ionic cleanliness (2.3.25) measured on as‑received boards and after reflow.
- 6. Flux residue (2.3.45) inspected under components; any trapped residue noted.
- 7. Wetting balance (2.4.14) performed on PCB pads; wetting time and force recorded.
- 8. Reflow profile documented (peak temp, soak time, ramp rates).
- 9. All test data compared across process variables (paste type, finish, profile).
- 10. Acceptance limits defined internally (void %, volatile content, ionic level).
Need to quantify voids or identify their root cause? Our lab performs X‑Ray, microsection, TGA, and ionic cleanliness testing per IPC‑TM‑650.
Request Void Analysis →IPC‑TM‑650 Test Methods Referenced: 2.4.52 (X‑Ray Inspection), 2.1.1 (Microsection), 2.3.40 (TGA), 2.3.25 (Ionic Cleanliness), 2.3.45 (Flux Residue), 2.4.14 (Wetting Balance).
Get Custom Quote
PRODUCTS CENTER


