ROSE Testing
Quality & Inspection Standards
PRODUCTS CENTER
Get Custom Quote
PRODUCTS CENTER
ROSE Testing – Resistivity of Solvent Extract, IPC Limits & Process Control
ROSE (Resistivity of Solvent Extract) testing is the industry workhorse for measuring ionic cleanliness of printed circuit boards. It is fast, inexpensive, and correlates well with field reliability – but only if done correctly. We have seen contract manufacturers pass ROSE at the factory, yet boards failed in the field from CAF and electrochemical migration. The culprit? A shift in the calibration curve, improper extraction volume, or using the wrong solvent ratio. Per IPC‑6012E §3.9.1, ionic contamination must not exceed 1.56 µg/cm² NaCl equivalent for Class 2/3 bare boards. This guide covers the three ROSE methods (dynamic, static, manual), calibration, acceptance limits, and common pitfalls that invalidate results.
Table of Contents
- What Is ROSE? – Principle, Limitations & NaCl Equivalent
- Three Test Methods: Manual, Dynamic & Static
- Calibration – Why It Fails and How to Do It Right
- Procedure Highlights: Extraction, Temperature, Solvent Ratio
- Acceptance Criteria: IPC‑6012 Limits & OEM Variations
- Common Pitfalls – False Pass & False Fail
- ROSE Testing Checklist (IPC‑Anchored)
- FAQ
1. What Is ROSE? – Principle, Limitations & NaCl Equivalent
ROSE measures the conductivity of a solvent extraction solution that has been in contact with the PCB surface. The higher the conductivity, the more ionic residues are present. Per IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25, results are reported as micrograms of sodium chloride equivalent per square centimeter (μg NaCl eq./cm²). This does not mean the residue is NaCl – it means the conductivity equals that amount of NaCl in solution.
Fundamental limitations:
- Does not identify specific ions (cannot distinguish chloride from bromide or organic acids).
- Does not measure non‑ionic residues (rosin, oils, particles).
- Does not measure insoluble ionic residues (e.g., certain flux activators that do not dissolve in the extraction solution).
- Temperature sensitive – readings change ±5% per °C if not compensated.
Despite these limitations, ROSE is an excellent process control tool. When properly calibrated and executed, it detects shifts in cleaning line efficiency, flux application, and handling contamination. For ion‑specific analysis, refer to IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.28 (Ion Chromatography).
In one CM audit, we found ROSE results consistently below 1.0 μg/cm², yet field failures from CAF were high. Re‑calibrating the ROSE meter revealed a 40% reading error – the actual contamination was 2.1 μg/cm². The CM had not calibrated the instrument in 18 months.
2. Three Test Methods: Manual, Dynamic & Static
IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25 describes three extraction methods. Each has advantages and disadvantages.
| Method | Description | Pros | Cons | Typical Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Manual (4.4) | IPA/DI water sprayed or poured over board, collected, measured offline | Low equipment cost, flexible | Operator‑dependent, slow | Low volume, R&D, audit |
| Dynamic (5.0) | Continuous circulation through test cell and ion exchange column | Automated, integrates over time | Expensive, slower cycle time | High volume, process monitoring |
| Static (6.0) | Fixed volume of IPA/DI water in test cell, stirred, conductivity measured | Fast, repeatable | Requires dedicated instrument (e.g., Omega meter) | Production lot acceptance |
Table 1: Comparison of ROSE methods. For most production QC, static ROSE (e.g., Omega meter) is preferred.
The static method (sealed bag extraction) described in IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25.1 has become popular because it uses a heated water bath (80°C, 60 minutes) and a small solvent volume, improving extraction efficiency for tight spaces (under BGAs). We recommend the sealed bag method for Class 3 assemblies.
3. Calibration – Why It Fails and How to Do It Right
Calibration is the most frequently mishandled aspect of ROSE testing. Per IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25 §4.3, a three‑point calibration using known NaCl concentrations is required. The calibration must be performed using the same solvent composition (75/25 or 50/50 IPA/DI water) as used for testing. Water alone is not acceptable.
Step‑by‑step calibration (manual method):
- Prepare 0.06 g/L NaCl standard solution (ACS reagent grade, dried at 105°C).
- Add 5 mL, 20 mL, and 25 mL of standard to separate 1L volumes of IPA/DI water (same ratio as test solvent).
- Measure conductivity of each solution at the test temperature (typically 23°C or 25°C).
- Plot conductivity vs. NaCl concentration (µg/L). The curve must be linear with R² ≥0.99.
- Use the curve to convert unknown sample conductivity to µg/L NaCl, then calculate µg/cm².
Common calibration errors we have observed:
- Using water instead of IPA/DI water – changes conductivity by 30%.
- Calibrating at room temperature but testing at a different temperature without compensation.
- Using old NaCl standards (microbial growth changes concentration).
- Not calibrating after changing solvent batch or probe.
In one case, a supplier's ROSE meter had not been calibrated for two years. Their reported 0.8 µg/cm² was actually 1.9 µg/cm². A $100 calibration saved a $200,000 lot rejection.
4. Procedure Highlights: Extraction, Temperature, Solvent Ratio
Three variables critically affect ROSE results. Control them tightly:
- Solvent ratio: IPC allows 75/25 or 50/50 IPA/DI water (v/v). Do not mix ratios. 75/25 extracts more polar residues; 50/50 is more aggressive on certain flux systems. Choose one and stick to it for all comparisons.
- Extraction temperature: For the sealed bag method (2.3.25.1), the water bath must be 80±2°C. Higher temperature extracts more ions – if the bath drifts to 85°C, results can increase by 20%.
- Extraction time: 60±5 minutes for the sealed bag method. Longer times extract more ions – a 90‑minute soak can give false failures.
- Board surface area calculation: For bare boards, area = length × width × 2. For assemblies, add an estimate for components (typically +10‑50%). Document the calculation.
Example calculation (static ROSE): A 10cm × 20cm bare board → area = 400 cm². Extraction volume = 620 mL (typical for bag). ROSE reading = 1.2 µg/cm². Interpretation: borderline but acceptable for Class 2/3 (limit 1.56). If the same board with the same residue had been tested at 50/50 instead of 75/25, the result might be 0.9 µg/cm² – artificially low.
5. Acceptance Criteria: IPC‑6012 Limits & OEM Variations
Per IPC‑6012E §3.9.1, the maximum allowable ionic contamination for bare printed boards (Classes 2 and 3) is 1.56 µg/cm² NaCl equivalent when tested per IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25 or 2.3.25.1. For assembled boards, the limit is typically the same unless otherwise specified.
However, many OEMs impose stricter limits:
- Telecom / server: 1.0 µg/cm² (tighter for high‑impedance analog circuits).
- Aerospace / military: 0.75 µg/cm² (per IPC‑6012ES or customer spec).
- Medical implantable: 0.5 µg/cm² (some require ion chromatography for verification).
Important: ROSE is a process control tool, not a reliability predictor. Passing 1.56 µg/cm² does not guarantee no electrochemical migration – certain ions (e.g., bromide) are more aggressive than NaCl at the same conductivity. For high‑reliability applications, use ion chromatography (IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.28) to quantify specific ions.
In a military program, boards passed ROSE at 1.2 µg/cm² but failed SIR (surface insulation resistance) testing. Ion chromatography revealed high bromide residues from a no‑clean flux. The ROSE reading was low because bromide has lower conductivity than chloride. The lesson: ROSE alone is insufficient for high‑reliability.
6. Common Pitfalls – False Pass & False Fail
False pass (accepting a dirty board):
- Incomplete extraction – solvent volume too low, temperature too low, time too short.
- Calibration error – under‑reporting conductivity.
- Using 50/50 solvent on a flux that is only soluble in 75/25.
- Surface area over‑estimated (makes µg/cm² appear lower).
False fail (rejecting a clean board):
- Contaminated extraction bag or vessel (use fresh, ion‑free bags per 2.3.25.1).
- Handling contamination – operators not wearing clean gloves.
- Solvent not de‑ionized (resistivity <16 MΩ·cm).
- Temperature too high during extraction or measurement.
In one audit, we traced a 0.2 µg/cm² false fail to the extraction bags: the lab had reused bags after a cursory rinse. Switching to single‑use bags eliminated the problem.
ROSE Testing Checklist (IPC‑Anchored)
- Specify solvent ratio in PO. Default is 75/25 IPA/DI water unless otherwise agreed.
- Calibrate daily (or before each test run) with three NaCl standards. R² must be ≥0.99.
- Use fresh, de‑ionized solvent. Resistivity ≥16 MΩ·cm.
- Calculate board surface area accurately. For bare boards: length × width × 2.
- Control extraction temperature: 80±2°C for sealed bag method.
- Use clean gloves and single‑use extraction bags. Do not reuse bags.
- Record extraction volume and temperature. Include in test report.
- If result exceeds limit, verify with ion chromatography. Rule out false pass/fail.
7. FAQ
Q: What is the difference between ROSE and ion chromatography (IC)?
A: ROSE measures total conductivity (all ions combined) and reports as NaCl equivalent. IC separates and quantifies individual ions (chloride, bromide, sulfate, sodium, etc.). ROSE is faster and cheaper; IC is required for root cause analysis and high‑reliability applications.
Q: Can I use ROSE on assembled boards with components?
A: Yes – IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25 allows it. However, component bodies trap residues and may not be fully extracted. The surface area calculation becomes approximate (add 10‑50% for component area). For precise measurements, use ion chromatography on extracted solution from assembled boards.
Q: What is the typical ROSE limit for no‑clean flux assembly?
A: No‑clean fluxes are designed to be left on the board, but ionic residues (activators) should still be below 1.56 µg/cm². Many no‑clean processes yield 0.5‑1.0 µg/cm². If ROSE exceeds 1.56, either the flux is not fully cured or the cleaning (if any) is inadequate.
Q: How often should I recalibrate the ROSE meter?
A: Daily or before each test run. The calibration curve can drift with temperature, probe fouling, and solvent batch changes. Many labs recalibrate weekly – we have seen 20% drift after 5 days. Daily calibration is cheap insurance.
Continue Reading – Cleanliness & Contamination Series
Related Manufacturing Capability
Inspection & Testing Capabilities
PCB and PCBA inspection, cleanliness verification and process-quality support for prototype and production builds.
If ROSE limits, ion chromatography, SIR testing, flux residue or contamination-related failure is a concern, submit the process requirements and available test data for an engineering review.
Request Cleanliness Engineering Review →References: IPC‑TM‑650 2.3.25, 2.3.25.1; IPC‑6012E §3.9.1; IPC‑TR‑583 (Ionic Cleanliness Testing). IPC‑TM‑650 Official Method.
Get Custom Quote
PRODUCTS CENTER


